Pele or Maradona? Debate will continue raging over who was greater

It was an argument that played out for years on terraces and in bars, on radio and on television. Brazil’s Pele won the World Cup an unprecedented three times as a player in 1958, 1962 and 1970 and put the small town of Santos on the map before conquering the United States with the New York Cosmos.

Maradona, who died at the age of 60 in 2020, guided Argentina to the World Cup in 1986 with perhaps the most influential performance ever at a major tournament, and lifted Napoli to unparalleled heights in Italy and Europe. The argument about whose legacy was greater so divided the football world that when Maradona was voted the player of the 20th century in a FIFA internet poll, there was widespread outrage, with many griping that Pele’s earlier career put him at a disadvantage with younger fans.

FIFA held another poll voted on by their own “football family”, won by Pele – allowing the pair to share the glory. Here Pele, the striker whose territory was the penalty box, a player who scored goals for fun and became Minister of Sport, more your quiet type of person,FIFA wrote at the time.

“There Maradona, possibly the most complete player ever, playmaker and goalscorer, technically brilliant, unpredictable and impulsive, both on and off the field, a player plagued by a variety of problems for many years.”

The cases made on both sides came with a host of subtexts: the Argentine versus the Brazilian, the man of the people versus the establishment figure, the party animal versus the quiet man, the rebel versus the conformist. Everyone took a side and the two protagonists were not shy about making their own feelings known.

Pele thought Maradona was gauche and undignified and Maradona thought Pele was a sell-out. As a player he was great ... but he thinks politically, Maradona said, in one of his kinder criticisms. Pele called the Argentine, who struggled with addiction, “a bad example” and much more besides. Still, the two South Americans got on well when they met for the first time in 1979, Maradona flying to Rio to meet Pele.

Pele was happy to counsel the budding star, and Maradona excited to be fulfilling his dream of meeting the Brazilian. But their relationship soured in 1982 after Pele criticised Maradona when he was sent off for stamping on a Brazilian in a World Cup tie in Spain. From then on, they spent decades criticising each other and then making up, with the praise as sincere as the insults.